Peer Reviewer Policy

PEER REVIEW POLICY

Peer Review System

Madinah: Jurnal Studi Islam is committed to maintaining the quality, originality, academic integrity, and relevance of published articles through a rigorous peer-review process.

For manuscripts processed before Volume 14 (2027), the journal applies a single-blind peer-review system. Under this system, reviewers’ identities are not disclosed to authors, while reviewers may have access to the authors’ identities.

Beginning with Volume 14 (2027), the journal will apply a double-blind peer-review system. Under this system, the identities of both authors and reviewers are concealed from each other throughout the review process. Authors are required to submit manuscripts prepared for anonymous review, and the editorial team will check and, where necessary, remove identifying information before the manuscripts are sent to reviewers.

The applicable review system is determined by the manuscript’s submission and review-processing arrangements under the journal’s editorial policy. Manuscripts processed under the previous policy will continue to follow the single-blind system, while manuscripts processed under the new policy for Volume 14 (2027) and subsequent volumes will follow the double-blind system.

Each manuscript that passes the initial editorial screening is evaluated by at least two independent reviewers with relevant expertise. The Editor-in-Chief or an authorized editor makes the final publication decision based on the reviewers’ recommendations, the manuscript’s academic quality, and its compliance with the journal’s editorial standards.

A. Initial Editorial Screening

All submitted manuscripts undergo an initial screening by the editorial team before being sent to reviewers. This process consists of the following stages.

1. Initial Screening (Zero Gate)

The initial screening is normally conducted within 1–7 days after submission. The editorial team checks whether the manuscript meets the journal’s basic requirements, including:

  1. Language: The manuscript is written in clear academic English or another language explicitly accepted by the journal.

  2. Abstracts: The manuscript includes abstracts and keywords in the languages required by the journal.

  3. Scope and relevance: The manuscript is relevant to the journal’s aims and scope, particularly the study of Islam and its relationship with society, education, culture, and community life.

  4. Originality and contribution: The manuscript demonstrates a clear research problem, a relevant research gap, and a potentially meaningful contribution to existing scholarship.

Manuscripts that do not meet the journal’s basic requirements may be returned to authors for correction or rejected without external review.

2. Editorial Desk Review

Manuscripts that pass the initial screening undergo a more detailed editorial assessment. This stage is normally completed within 1–4 weeks, depending on the volume of submissions and the complexity of the manuscript.

The desk review covers the following aspects:

  1. Formatting and structure: Compliance with the journal’s manuscript template, structure, citation style, and submission requirements.

  2. Similarity screening: The manuscript is checked using plagiarism-detection software. The similarity score should normally not exceed 25%. The similarity score is not the sole basis for an editorial decision; the editorial team also examines the nature and sources of the similarities.

  3. Research components: Where relevant to the research design, the manuscript should clearly explain the research gap, ethical considerations, researcher reflexivity, and community context.

  4. Reference quality: Authors are encouraged to prioritize relevant, recent, and credible scholarly sources, including articles from accredited or reputable academic journals. Any specific minimum percentage stated in the Author Guidelines will be applied consistently.

  5. Section balance: The manuscript should maintain a reasonable balance among the introduction, research methods, results and discussion, and conclusion, appropriate to the research design and article type.

The editorial team may request revisions before external review or reject manuscripts that fail to meet the journal’s standards.

B. Reviewer Assignment

The Editor-in-Chief or an authorized editor assigns manuscripts to reviewers whose academic expertise and research interests are relevant to the subject matter of the submission.

The journal normally appoints at least two independent reviewers for each manuscript that passes the editorial screening.

Reviewers are selected based on their expertise, academic qualifications, publication record, and ability to provide an objective assessment. Reviewers must disclose any potential conflicts of interest and decline assignments when they cannot provide an impartial review.

For manuscripts processed under the single-blind system applicable before Volume 14 (2027), reviewers’ identities are concealed from authors, but reviewers may be aware of authors’ identities.

For manuscripts processed under the double-blind system beginning with Volume 14 (2027), the editorial team takes reasonable steps to conceal both authors’ and reviewers’ identities. Authors must remove names, affiliations, acknowledgements, and other identifying details from the anonymized manuscript where these could reveal authorship. Author-identifying information may be retained in the separate metadata or title-page file when required by the submission system.

C. Peer-Review Process

The external review process is normally completed within 1–4 weeks after the manuscript has been assigned to reviewers. Actual processing time may vary depending on reviewer availability, the complexity of the manuscript, and the need to invite replacement reviewers.

Reviewers are asked to assess the manuscript according to the following criteria:

  1. Relevance and scope: The manuscript fits the aims and scope of Madinah: Jurnal Studi Islam.

  2. Originality and contribution: The manuscript offers an identifiable contribution to knowledge, theory, methodology, or practice.

  3. Research problem and literature: The research problem is clearly formulated and supported by relevant literature.

  4. Methodological rigor: The research design, methods, data sources, and analytical procedures are appropriate and adequately explained.

  5. Analysis and discussion: Findings are presented clearly and discussed critically in relation to relevant theories, previous research, and the study’s context.

  6. Ethical integrity: The manuscript addresses relevant research ethics and demonstrates responsible treatment of research participants and data.

  7. Structure and clarity: The manuscript is logically organized and written in an appropriate academic style.

  8. References: The references are relevant, sufficiently current where appropriate, and cited consistently.

Reviewers provide constructive comments and recommend one of the following decisions:

  • Accept without revision.

  • Accept subject to minor revisions.

  • Reconsider after major revisions.

  • Reject.

The editorial team may seek additional reviews when the reviewers’ recommendations differ substantially or when further expertise is required.

D. Review and Publication Timeline

The journal aims to process manuscripts efficiently while maintaining rigorous editorial standards. The indicative timeline is as follows:

  1. Initial screening: 1–7 days.

  2. Editorial desk review: Normally 1–4 weeks.

  3. External peer review: Normally 1–4 weeks after reviewer assignment.

  4. Author revision: Normally 14 days for minor revisions and 21 days for major revisions, unless another deadline is agreed with the editor.

  5. Final editorial evaluation: Depending on the completeness of the revisions and the need for further assessment.

These periods are indicative rather than guaranteed. The total time from submission to final decision varies according to the manuscript’s quality, reviewer availability, revision requirements, and editorial workload. The journal will communicate significant delays to authors when appropriate.

E. Editorial Decisions

The final decision on publication rests with the Editor-in-Chief or an authorized editor. The decision is based on the reviewers’ comments, the manuscript’s academic merit, its relevance to the journal, and compliance with editorial and ethical standards.

The journal may reject a manuscript at any stage if serious problems are identified, including plagiarism, research misconduct, unreliable findings, ethical violations, or substantial failure to meet the journal’s requirements.

An invitation to revise does not guarantee acceptance. Revised manuscripts must adequately address the reviewers’ and editors’ comments before a final decision is made.

F. Manuscript Revision

Authors are required to respond to reviewers’ and editors’ comments in a clear and systematic manner. A response document should identify each comment and explain the revision made or provide a reasoned response when a suggested change is not adopted.

Authors should submit revised manuscripts within the deadline specified by the editor. The usual deadlines are:

  • Minor revision: 14 days.

  • Major revision: 21 days.

Extensions may be granted at the editor’s discretion upon a reasonable request. Revised manuscripts may be returned to the original reviewers when further expert assessment is necessary.

For manuscripts processed under the double-blind system, authors must ensure that the revised manuscript remains appropriately anonymized during any further review.

G. Final Editorial Evaluation

After the revision stage, the editorial team evaluates whether the authors have adequately addressed the reviewers’ and editors’ comments. The editor may accept the manuscript, request further revisions, send it for another review round, or reject it.

Accepted manuscripts proceed to copyediting, proofreading, layout, and publication according to the journal’s editorial workflow. Acceptance is subject to completion of all required editorial, ethical, and administrative procedures.

H. Confidentiality

The editorial team and reviewers must treat submitted manuscripts and the review process as confidential. Manuscripts must not be shared with unauthorized parties or used for personal research, professional advantage, or other purposes unrelated to the review process.

Reviewers must not disclose the contents of a manuscript or the details of their review without authorization from the journal. The journal handles author and reviewer information in accordance with its editorial procedures and applicable privacy requirements.

For the double-blind system introduced beginning with Volume 14 (2027), the editorial team will take reasonable measures to protect the anonymity of both parties throughout the review process. Complete anonymity cannot be guaranteed in every case, particularly when a manuscript’s content or prior dissemination makes its authorship recognizable.

I. Review Integrity and Conflicts of Interest

Reviewers must provide fair, objective, evidence-based, and constructive assessments. Personal criticism, discriminatory remarks, and unsupported allegations are not acceptable.

Reviewers must declare any actual or potential conflicts of interest, including personal, professional, institutional, or financial relationships that could affect their impartiality. The editor will determine whether a reviewer should be replaced.

Authors must ensure that their submissions are original, properly cited, and ethically conducted. Any suspected plagiarism, duplicate publication, data fabrication, falsification, or other research misconduct will be handled in accordance with the journal’s publication ethics policy.

J. Policy Implementation

This policy distinguishes between the peer-review arrangements applied before and from Volume 14 (2027):

  1. Manuscripts processed before Volume 14 (2027): The journal applies the single-blind peer-review policy in force at the time of processing.

  2. Manuscripts processed for Volume 14 (2027) and subsequent volumes: The journal applies the double-blind peer-review system, with reasonable measures to conceal the identities of authors and reviewers.

  3. Transition and consistency: The journal will communicate the applicable review requirements to authors, editors, and reviewers and will implement the anonymization procedure consistently for manuscripts subject to the double-blind system.

The journal will periodically review this policy to ensure that its peer-review practices remain transparent, fair, and consistent with accepted standards of scholarly publishing.